Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Spicy Vodka Fusilli
Pizza Sub
Meatball Sub
About
Papa Giorgios
Welcome to Papa Giorgios, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio, located at 5216 Bethel Center Mall. This establishment specializes in crafting mouthwatering pizzas that embody the essence of New York style cooking. With a reputation for quality and quick service, Papa Giorgios has become a favorite among locals seeking delicious, no-nonsense cuisine.
The moment you step inside, you're greeted by a welcoming atmosphere and a staff that feels more like family than employees. The owner, Dave, is a memorable presence behind the counter, known for his friendly demeanor and genuine approach, making every visit feel personal. It’s the kind of place where you can enjoy a hearty meal while sharing a laugh with the staff.
At Papa Giorgios, the menu boasts an array of options that cater to every craving, from classic pizzas to inventive salads and hearty strombolis. Highlights include:
- New York Style Pizzas: Each slice is a delightful balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings that make it perfect for folding. Satisfied customers rave about the quality ingredients and the flavor-packed Ezzo Old World pepperoni.
- Fresh Salads: A refreshing house salad is available, featuring crisp iceberg lettuce, mozzarella, and vibrant toppings like red bell peppers and pepperoni, all expertly dressed for just $5.99.
- Stromboli and Calzones: Both options allow you to customize with your choice of ingredients, served with a side of marinara for dipping. At only $12.99, they are an irresistible way to indulge.
What sets Papa Giorgios apart is not just the food but the flavors that transport you back to mom and pop pizzerias of your childhood. The crust has an ideal crispness that complements the toppings without overpowering them—perfectly chewy and reheatable in your convection oven or air fryer for a late-night snack. Customers also recommend enhancing your pizza with garlic and fresh basil, taking your experience to an even higher level of deliciousness.
But pizza isn't the only star here. The carbonara with guanciale is a surprising feature that has captured the hearts of diners, offering a rich, authentic taste that many have found to be a true culinary gem.
If you’re in the Columbus area and craving some classic pizza in a friendly setting, make Papa Giorgios your go-to destination. As numerous reviews suggest, once you experience their delicious offerings, you’ll understand why this local favorite deserves your patronage. Remember, your order will be ready before you can even park, so you won't have to wait long to enjoy a satisfying meal. Head over, grab that pizza, and let yourself indulge in a slice of perfection!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Thanks for your order, your pizzas will be ready in 10 minutes I still get a kick out of that line every time I order for pickup, but they aint lyin. None of that 45 minute wait time like the other local spots or chains they make delicious NY style pizzas with zero big business bloat that might otherwise have you reconsidering a different option on a busy weekend evening. The staff is always cool and accommodating whether on the phone or in person, and Davethe boss manis an absolute legend. The kind of guy you want to be behind the counter when picking up a pie. Old school, personable, and no nonsense but always ready to joke or hand out a smile at a whim. With a perfect sauce to cheese to topping ratio, every slice is suitably dressed to fold without a flop, and before you know it, youve eaten way too many slices before youve even parked in your driveway. The crust is great it doesnt try to take center stage, but it also doesnt get lost in the sauce. It has a great crisp chew and reheats perfectly in your convection oven or air fryer. Id be doing you a disservice if I didnt tell you to include garlic and basil on every pizza you order here. Cosi delizioso! Finally, once youve had enough pizza, do yourself and try the carbonara with guancialeif they havent sold out. A true gem of an old school mom and pop spot that everyone waxes poetic about but doesnt always patronize as much as they should. Go and grab that order for pickup. Itll be ready before you get there and gone before youre home. ”
“ We love the pizza and sides! Reminds me of places in my moms hometown in NJ. They have 2 tables to eat in and we do! We dine in because we love talking to the staff! Killer combo is our favorite!!! Try the Roman bread! Its new and amazing! ”
“ Great NY style pizza! This spot years ago had a great new style pizza then a new place took over that had bad thin crust. Now its another New York style place that AMAZING. The pizza has tons of flavor, clearly great quality ingredients. I love the Ezzo Old World pep they use and the cheese is perfect stringy. This is my new favorite pizza place in the area. Finally something great!! ”
“ I never thought I would find a grease stain sexy! Their pizza is delicious, service friendly, and best of all around two minutes away from where I live. Nothing negative to say and will be getting pizza from here frequently. Oh and not sure if their blue cheese and garlic sauces are made in house but they are delicious!! ”
“ My first time tonight, theres one word to describe my supreme pizza QUALITY!! It was delicious and Ill be back for more!! Fresh fast and delicious thanks Dave. ”
“ Like others have said a classic pizza place. The pies remind me of NYNJ style. Definitely close to top of my list for Columbus area pizzeria. My wife got the cauliflower crust not glutenfree, just watching carbs and it also tasted good. ”
“ Papa Giorgios Pizza is the best! From their excellent New York style crust, to their creamymelty NOT rubbery! cheese, to sauce that tastes so fresh! They make a bangin stromboli too golden and crispy outside with the perfect cheese to meat balance inside. The homemade buns and Ezzo meats make for subs that are just superb! If meat isnt your thing, there are lots of great veggie toppingsfillings. They offer excellent, fresh salads too! My self proclaimed pizzasnob friends from New York are big fans. Papa Giorgios was a happy discovery for them. And I cant NOT mention how incredibly nice everyone has always been EVERY time weve gone. The owner, the manager, the associates.... everyone. Super fun and friendly! ”
“ You want real Italian food this is where you go. Im 80 Italian and when I bite into a piece of this pie, its the real deal. No none of that fake frozen dough not the fake cheese. Do you want a real Italian meal stop in here I would recommend this restaurant anyone and everyone the camaraderie is amazing. The owner is back there making pizzas. He really cares about the quality of his product and the look of his business. I appreciate the absolute pride he has in his business and the affordability. This is the place ”